The Eternal Debate Between Streamlight TLR 1 Vs Surefire X300

This post may contain affiliate links. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission (no added cost for you).

For a long time, people have been carrying on an argument on Streamlight TLR 1 vs Surefire X300. Well, it is time we break down things for you so that you know which one to choose. Both the tactical lights are similar in some ways but in order to select the right one you have to know their differences properly.

Here are the differences between them that will assist you in getting the right one for you. Both tactical lights are manufactured by reputed brands so users can expect good value for their money. Take a look at what these tactical lights have to offer.

Specifications Of The Streamlight TLR 1

This is a tactical flashlight that produces a very bright light. This is super easy to attach to any gun within a short time. Here are some of the specifications of this light.

  • This is made from very strong aluminum that has been given an anodized finish. The unit is resistant to any harsh compact.
  • The light does not weigh too much, it is very compact. The unit can perform for 2.5 hours non-stop. The tactical light is powered by CR123 batteries that have a storage life of 10 years
  • The LED bulb produces an output of 300 Lumens

Specifications Of The Surefire X300

Here are some of the key specifications of the tactical light that are worth taking notice of:

  • The tactical light is made of very strong aluminum with an anodized finishing
  • The unit features an ambidextrous toggle which makes it very easy for the users to handle this tactical light
  • The unit is waterproof, dustproof, shockproof, and resistant to any impact. This means that the unit is very durable which means is it will last for a very long time
  • The LED bulb has an output of 600 lumens, which is very impressive

Difference Between Streamlight TLR 1 vs Surefire X300?

Here are the key differences between the Streamlight TLR 1 and the Surefire X300 that will help you choose the best option of the two. Have a look and make an educated decision so that you can get the best out of your firearms.

Usage On Long Guns

There is no doubt that most of these lights are manufactured for handguns but they can also be used for shotguns and rifles. The good thing is that they work just fine. These lights come with rifle kits. What are these kits? They are nothing backplates that are good substitutes for the thumb plates by including a switch to control the pressure.

These switches are connected to a pad which again is attached to a panel. When a user applies pressure this will prompt the light to turn on so you see that these switches are very easy to operate.

When you consider Streamlight’s pressure switch, it must be clarified that it is way easier to handle. In addition, it does not cost you a lot of money. However, Surefire’s switch sports a sturdy finishing. The good thing is that both are easy to operate.

Typically long guns have a good range when you consider X300 you will see that it is quite light. It produces a beam at 8 degrees, which covers an impressive distance. The Streamlight is also good but since it has a big lamp it cannot be used with a handgun. This is most suited for shotguns.

Usage On Handguns

These are weapon lights that are created for handguns, as most users look for lights to use with their handguns. Before you go out and buy these lights there are couple of factors like beam type, design, ergonomics, and purpose that needs to be taken into consideration.


The Streamlight has a beam that has a 20-degree beam and can be used with a handgun without any hesitation. Now we know that handguns are most used for close-range shooting so if they are used with lights that produce a beam of 20 degrees, the results are outstanding.

Now, when we look at Surefire X300 this is most suitable for military shooters and the police. This produces a very powerful beam at an angle of 8 degrees and can be extensively used outdoors.


The good thing is that these lights come with ambidextrous paddles. This makes the light is to operate. The momentary modes on the lights are very useful during tactical situations. Users also have the option of using grip switches with these lights, so as soon as you grip your gun the light comes on.


There is not much of a difference in the design. The only differentiating factor is that Streamlight weighs slightly more than Surefire. They are both impressive and do not add unnecessary bulk to the gun. Even with a fully loaded magazine then the gun will feel light

You will notice that the X300 happens to be a bit longer in comparison to TLR-1. The difference is nothing to write home about. The longer light may have a slight edge over the other as it prevents too much of carbon build-up. This is one of the aspects of the X300.

Battery Life

Both the lights require two batteries (CR 123 Type).  When it comes to X300 it works 1.5 hours nonstop. The Streamlight can function to 2.5 hours on a full charge, which is quite impressive.

Power And Price

Price is something that needs to be taken into consideration, so the TLR is cheaper when compared to Surefire X300. The difference in beam is very important. If you look at the beam from Streamlight it resembles a spotlight. The beam has an angle of 20 degrees, this is ideal for usage indoors.

Surefire on the other hand comes with a dual setting beam. The first setting produces a beam of 8 degrees and the second setting produces a beam of 45 degrees.

How to Choose: Streamlight TLR 1 or Surefire X300?

Now, this could be a tricky one. Nonetheless, we have solved this puzzle too. Below are some pointers that can help:


The best way to choose from the two is to go through the different specifications and compare. See if they will fulfill your requirements. They are both very good and their quality and performance are both impressive.


They are also priced very differently so you need to fix a budget as it will help you narrow down on what you are looking for. Like most products these too have their weaknesses and you should study them not because you do not want to buy them but because you want to know how to work around the weaknesses.


Streamlight is best suited for shotguns and handguns and Surefire is best suited for rifles. Well, in our books both are winners as they have a lot to offer to the users. So, you have a lot to benefit from these two types of tactical light.

When it comes to debating on Streamlight TLR 1 vs Surefire X300 running a comparison is a little tough. However, you must know that they are both very well made and they will last for a long time to come so you will have to seek replacements anytime soon. 

You can be rest assured that no matter which one you choose, you will not regret it in the least. So, if you are very eager to step up on your shooting experience go ahead and get them today. Do not miss out on these two tactical lights under any circumstances. Good luck with your search.

Featured image source: Southern Connecticut Airsoft

Leave a Comment